Flavors & Pricing

Home Weddings Showers Fun Flavors & Pricing Contact

Cake Flavors (If you prefer Organic, Gluten Free, Sugar Free, or Vegan ingredients please specify with your order)

  • French Vanilla
  • Chocolate Fudge
  • White Chocolate
  • White Chocolate Amaretto
  • Vanilla Coconut Cream
  • Pumpkin Latte, Vanilla Latte, Caramel Latte, Hazelnut Latte
  • Maple or Maple Spice
  • Vanilla Cinnamon
  • Champagne
  • Rich Lemon or Orange
  • White Chocolate Lemon (Subtle lemon flavor)
  • Butterscotch Rum
  • Italian cream (has a small amount of coconut)
  • Honey cream
  • Irish Cream
  • Cheesecake cake
  • Cookies-N-Cream
  • Chocolate Chip
  • Banana or Banana choc. chip
  • Pistachio
  • Orange spice Carrot cake
  • Apple or apple spice
  • Red Velvet
  • Peanut Butter 
  • Gluten, Egg, Wheat, and Peanut FREE cakes in Chocolate or Vanilla
  • Buttercream (vanilla, white chocolate, chocolate fudge, caramel, amaretto, coconut, hazelnut, Mexican Hot Chocolate, Dulce de leche, Mint)
  • Italian Meringue Buttercream
  • Marshmallow Fondant
  • Chocolate Ganache (white, milk, dark, or mint) These are delicious mixed with any of your favorite liquors
  • Cream Cheese (Honey Spice or regular)
  • Maple-Butter Frosting
  • Peggy's Buttercream (my favorite creation) 

Try one of our new "SIGNITURE" chocolate dipped cupcakes with any of your favorite flavor combos!

  • Vanilla cream
  • Chocolate (Dark, Milk or White) mousse or ganache
  • Chocolate Kahlua Cream
  • Irish Cream (with or without alcohol)
  • Cheesecake mousse
  • Grand Marnier Cream (You can substitute your favorite liquor)
  • Cookies-n-Cream
  • Vanilla, Snickers Cream
  • White Chocolate Amaretto custard or Cream
  • Bluberry Cream
  • Apple or apple spice
  • Strawberry cream
  • Apricot cream
  • Raspberry cream or Raspberry Mango
  • Morello Cherry cream
  • Passion Fruit cream
  • Orange Creamscicle
  • Latte (choose any flavor or just plain) cream
  • Buttercream (made with any flavor)
  • Mexican Hot Chocolate Buttercream or mousse
  • Bavarian Cream (can be mixed with any of the fruit flavors)
  • Lemon Curd or cream
  • Peanut Butter Mousse
  • Creme Brulee
  • Cappuccino Custard
  • Mint or Mint Chip Cream
  • Cannoli Cream (made thick and original or as a mousse)
  • Butterscotch custard or cream
  • Pistachio cream
  • Dulce de leche (translated in Spanish it means "Sweet of Milk". Similar to caramel.)

It would be impossible to list every flavor. This is a list of the most popular flavors. I love making new things, so feel free to order any of your favorite flavor combinations.


Wedding, Anniversary and Special Occasion cakes.... Start at $3.95 per serving

Cupcakes..... Start at $1.50 per cupcake (this price includes cream filled cupcakes)

Individual cakes....Start at $4.00

Croquembouche....Start at $.75 each

Truffles............Start at $1 each (perfect for favors)

Cookies............Start at $1

Mini Chocolate Apples....Start at $1 each (these are bite size)

Cake Pops........$1 each

Cheese Cake Pops.......$2 each

Dipped Strawberries.....$1 each (seasonal only)

Basic local delivery (within 10 miles of Carthage NY).....Free

Anywhere outside of 20 miles......  $1.50 per mile 

 Price of cakes increase with the complexity and design of the cake. 

Peggy's Sweet Creations is open by appointment only. Once your wedding is booked we can schedule a complimentary cake tasting at your earliest convenience.